(no subject)
23/4/14 11:56I liked Rae Carson's The Bitter Kingdom well enough but increasingly feel like I'm just not on the right wavelength when it comes to traditional/epic YA fantasy. (I am trying not to be hung up on "Why couldn't I get Sparks and Ashes to work????" but I would like to try to sell it eventually to someone...)
Of course, it's also 3rd in a trilogy where I haven't read the other two books -- it's a book I have to present on for a library booktalk -- and I'm sure that doesn't help. I was able to parse the plot that had come before just fine, but felt like there was a lot of character development that would've felt more meaningful with more setup.
Part of the problem may be that I'm not very interested in, and tried to write a fantasy novel entirely without, long journeys through the wilderness and nobles doing politics. (My issue with politics in fantasy is a bit like my issue with science in hard science fiction: you can deal with it at a simplistic level and get everything wrong, or you can deal with it at a sophisticated level and be kind of boring and pedantic, and it takes a really brilliant writer to not fall into either of those.)
Of course, it's also 3rd in a trilogy where I haven't read the other two books -- it's a book I have to present on for a library booktalk -- and I'm sure that doesn't help. I was able to parse the plot that had come before just fine, but felt like there was a lot of character development that would've felt more meaningful with more setup.
Part of the problem may be that I'm not very interested in, and tried to write a fantasy novel entirely without, long journeys through the wilderness and nobles doing politics. (My issue with politics in fantasy is a bit like my issue with science in hard science fiction: you can deal with it at a simplistic level and get everything wrong, or you can deal with it at a sophisticated level and be kind of boring and pedantic, and it takes a really brilliant writer to not fall into either of those.)