![[personal profile]](https://www.dreamwidth.org/img/silk/identity/user.png){kind=small}
I picked up an issue of Bungei Shunju a couple of weeks ago out of a vague but recurring sense that I should have more vocabulary for current events and politics and stuff. I am still sad that Ronza is no longer being published; Sekai is a bit too staid for my tastes; all of the other current events opinion magazines at Kinokuniya have a reputation for being right-wing, Bungei Shunju included, but I thought because of its good reputation (it's the magazine in which the Akutagawa prize is announced every year), and because it's not exclusively a political magazine, it wouldn't be so rightwingy.
...So obviously "To The People of Japan" was the wrong article to read (日本国民に告ぐ, by 藤原正彦. Who is a retired math professor. OBVIOUSLY he knows more about Japanese history than a historian does）. But I'm pretty fascinated by rightwingy Japanese nationalism, and if I actually knew enough to write a post about it than maybe I would, but I don't.
I'm making a post about it because today I came upon an idea that utterly gobsmacked me.
One of the things that occurred in the wake of the American occupation of Japan was the official writing reform, which declared that newspapers, magazines, and official legal and governmental documents had to restrict themselves to an official list of 1850 kanji. I'm not sure how many were in use before then -- prewar literature is notably more difficult to read, but for any number of reasons, not just the higher number of kanji. At any rate, the author declared that the writing reform was an American plot to destroy Japanese culture and make Japanese people stupid.
...
Per Wikipedia, he's hardly the first person to think so, and I am trying to be empathetic and think about how I would feel if, for example, the government suddenly said that I had to spell "through" as "thru" and "knight" as "nite." That's not a very good analogy, but I can't think of a better one for English. And, to be sure, I don't want to discount the effects of cultural imperialism. But I try to picture a bunch of bureaucrats sitting around a table and rubbing their hands evilly together. "I know! We'll crush their culture by making them spell 倦む as あぐむ!"
...I guess I'm biased because my linguistics classes always emphasized that the true form of a language is the spoken language, not whatever system you use to write it down with. On the other hand, if you had a fantasy world where writing was literally mystical power, you've got a story there.
...So obviously "To The People of Japan" was the wrong article to read (日本国民に告ぐ, by 藤原正彦. Who is a retired math professor. OBVIOUSLY he knows more about Japanese history than a historian does）. But I'm pretty fascinated by rightwingy Japanese nationalism, and if I actually knew enough to write a post about it than maybe I would, but I don't.
I'm making a post about it because today I came upon an idea that utterly gobsmacked me.
One of the things that occurred in the wake of the American occupation of Japan was the official writing reform, which declared that newspapers, magazines, and official legal and governmental documents had to restrict themselves to an official list of 1850 kanji. I'm not sure how many were in use before then -- prewar literature is notably more difficult to read, but for any number of reasons, not just the higher number of kanji. At any rate, the author declared that the writing reform was an American plot to destroy Japanese culture and make Japanese people stupid.
...
Per Wikipedia, he's hardly the first person to think so, and I am trying to be empathetic and think about how I would feel if, for example, the government suddenly said that I had to spell "through" as "thru" and "knight" as "nite." That's not a very good analogy, but I can't think of a better one for English. And, to be sure, I don't want to discount the effects of cultural imperialism. But I try to picture a bunch of bureaucrats sitting around a table and rubbing their hands evilly together. "I know! We'll crush their culture by making them spell 倦む as あぐむ!"
...I guess I'm biased because my linguistics classes always emphasized that the true form of a language is the spoken language, not whatever system you use to write it down with. On the other hand, if you had a fantasy world where writing was literally mystical power, you've got a story there.
Tags: